I've noticed something in a movie I've seen lately (The Divine Secrets of the Ya-Ya Sisterhood) and in commercials for Secondhand Lions that stands out to me. Something that feasibly ruins a movie for people watching it: when an actor has been grossly miscast.
This can be because they're acting persona doesn't match the character, because they just don't have the right look (they're too pretty to play a plain part, or too intelligent to play dumb), or they're just the wrong nationality.
Now, don't go getting pissed about that last one. Here's what I mean by it. The two glaringly obvious examples of this come from the two movies I listed above. Maggie Smith and Michael Caine. Both British. Both asked to play Southerners. Both totally and completely wrong for playing Southerners. They're fine accents. But folks, when I'm watching a movie about the South, or in which people are required to have Southern accents, if you don't pull off at least a slightly plausible accent, it's not going to work.
So, for everyone, name someone who was miscast in a movie, and give why. I'll start things off.
1. Maggie Smith, The Divine Secrets Of The Ya-Ya Sisterhood - Implausible southern accent
2. Michael Caine, Secondhand Lions - Implausible southern accent
3. Kevin Spacey, K-Pax - Too intelligent for the role/couldn't get the eyes to match the character
This can be because they're acting persona doesn't match the character, because they just don't have the right look (they're too pretty to play a plain part, or too intelligent to play dumb), or they're just the wrong nationality.
Now, don't go getting pissed about that last one. Here's what I mean by it. The two glaringly obvious examples of this come from the two movies I listed above. Maggie Smith and Michael Caine. Both British. Both asked to play Southerners. Both totally and completely wrong for playing Southerners. They're fine accents. But folks, when I'm watching a movie about the South, or in which people are required to have Southern accents, if you don't pull off at least a slightly plausible accent, it's not going to work.
So, for everyone, name someone who was miscast in a movie, and give why. I'll start things off.
1. Maggie Smith, The Divine Secrets Of The Ya-Ya Sisterhood - Implausible southern accent
2. Michael Caine, Secondhand Lions - Implausible southern accent
3. Kevin Spacey, K-Pax - Too intelligent for the role/couldn't get the eyes to match the character